Powered By Blogger

Friday, February 25, 2011

Disaster of 2010

A.G.Pirzada
Ex-Chief Economist, Govt. of Sindh
The deadliest weather related disaster of 2010 still continues to unfold in Pakistan since July 29, 2010, where heavy monsoon rains had triggered flooding that left over 2,000 people dead.
Millions of homes, in thousands of villages and towns were destroyed. According to reports, over 20 Million people were affected by this disaster - more than the 2004 Indonesia Tsunami, 2005 Pakistan Earthquake, and 2010 Haiti Earthquake combined.
Infrastructure such as dams, power stations, roads, bridges, schools, health facilities, crops, agriculture wells, and drinking water hand pumps were severely damaged or destroyed.
The losses caused by the unprecedented floods of August, 2010 in Sindh alone, were estimated to have been over Rs 600 million.
More than 8.0 million persons became homeless and a large number were sheltered in government’s 3,500 relief camps in the province.
A substantial number of homeless persons are reported to be still in the relief camps. Since the assessment of losses caused by the flood was out of the purview of Federal Flood Commission therefore the Sindh government does not accept the statistics of this Commission.
Sindh was severely affected by the flood, with worst displacement, the province had ever seen in its history. The socio-economic infrastructure in 8 districts viz: Kashmore, Shikarpur, Jaccobabad, Shahdadkot, Larkana, Dadu, and Jam shoro on the right bank and Thatta, on the left bank of Indus, was severely affected. The major cause for this large scale devastation was the two breaches at Tori and Thatta Bunds. It is claimed that heavy rainfall for five days in Koh-e-Suleman, Rojhan and Sukkur areas led to a sudden increase in the river water flows by over 100,000 cusecs which resulted in over topping and created a breach in the river embankment at Tori bund near Kandhkot. Simultaneously, the high tide phenomenon in Arabian Sea is also said to have resulted in hindering / blocking the river flows into the sea, raising pressure and causing breaches in the bunds in the hinterland in Thatta.
According to the figures given by government spokesperson on the magnitude of disaster, more than 10 million people were affected, 200 deaths reported and over 1000 injured. Over 7274 villages, 43 towns, over 2.2 million acres of cropland were inundated, while over 300 rice and other mills, factories and petrol pumps were reported damaged.
Initial estimates had suggested a total loss in the province exceeding Rs. 446.88 billion with Rs. 122.1 billion in Agriculture sector on account of damage to crops in 3,000,000 tons of grains, cotton and sugar cane. Livestock sector suffered a loss of Rs 11.l4 billion on account of 200,000 animals; Irrigation, Rs 52 billion; and Rs 37.5 billion for the destruction of 8,000 km Roads.
Total loss to the Housing sector was Rs 134.3 billion because of damage to 1,021,000 houses; while in Health sector, the loss was estimated at Rs 2.60 billion, as 100 health centers have been damaged. Total loss to the Education on account of damage to 4,600 units was estimated at Rs 26.90, Rs 40 billion to Municipal Infrastructure as 43 towns have been affected with a loss of Rs 10 billion to government buildings.
The provincial government has tried its best to help and assist the affecties in rehabilitating them through financial as well as material assistance however, it does not seem to be sufficient and enough……….Much more needs to be done.
El Nino and the Global Warming phenomenon should be taken into account………which says the cycle may continue for period not less than seven years……..! February is almost half way through. The next flood / aabkaliani season is not very far off. We must take some fool proof steps, immediate as well as long term to avoid such disasters or at least reduce their impact in future.
Government of Sindh may consider the following;
• Immediate repairs and rehabilitation of Tori Bund at the over topping site and restoration of bunds in all the affected districts including Thatta.
• Immediate and concrete steps to strengthen all the flood protection embankments / bunds in general, on both the banks of the river.
• Removal of all privately raised bunds and illegal structures in the bed / natural course of the river, obstructing free flow of water.
• Removal of encroachments from inside the bund walls on both the sides of the river at Sukkur….(1) to allow more quantity of water to flow, reducing the pressure on the old structure of Sukkur Barrage.
• Removal of illegal islands allowed through siltation around Bakhar Fort, Sadhu Belo and Sukkur Barrage…. (2-i,ii,iii).
• Dredging of river and canals on regular basis.
• Flushing of drains during aabkaliani season on regular basis in the command areas of all the three barrages.
• Feeding Manchar Lake on regular basis every year making it a standby Escape / Reservoir with an appropriate outlet.
• Repairs, Maintenance and Rehabilitation of all Irrigation Infra structures on yearly basis by fixing targets for physical works as well as achieving Honesty levels.
• Reduction of pressure on all the three barrages through construction of Escapes / Spill ways and By passes, viz;

Guddu Barrage ……
Deep dredging / excavation of Rainee canal and its extension by an other 5-10 k.ms allowing flow of at least three times the flow of water in cutting and connecting it with the historical bed of Rainee-Hakra-Ghaghar-Sarswati Rivers (3-i,ii,iii). This abandoned river bed is very conveniently being used by Punjab for drainage of its affluent towards Sindh through the desert.

Sukkur Barrage……..
Benazir Canal…..

• Sukkur Barrage was constructed in 1932 having 64 gates with a capacity of about 12 lac cusecs of water.
• With 16 gates permanently closed the current capacity of this old structure stands reduced to 9 lac cusecs only.
• Water passing through the encroached narrow passage gains higher speed to pass through the barrage.
• Sindhu on account of lack of dredging and encroachment on both the banks at Sukkur has narrowed.
• During the last flood season, a great risk was taken at the cost of the old and a comparatively weaker structure of the barrage, the irrigation system, the agriculture and the over- all economy of Sindh and foolishly, the flows of about 11.5 lac cusecs were allowed to pass through the barrage for more than three days.
• What if the barrage or a portion of it had washed away………!
• Repairs and / or Reconstruction of Sukkur barrage would have been too costly and out of question.
On account of its importance, age and the current capacity of 9 lac cusecs, there is no need to take the smallest risk of allowing more water but restrict the flow to about 8 – 8.5 lac cusecs and divert excess water to bye-pass the barrage through an Escape.
As a feasible alternate, both from technical and economical point of view, the Government of Sindh may;

• Revive the old course of a branch of the river, some five k.ms upstream of the barrage and two k.ms north of Rohri town near Ali Wahan….(4).
• A spill-way may be constructed, that may allow additional water to flow automatically in the old and abandoned Nara river bed (the moment water flows at the Sukkur barrage reach 8 – 8.5 lac cusecs).
• The spilled water may join the new Nara canal at Arore (5).
• With some extended dredging etc: a portion of the Nara canal may take the additional quantity of spilled water till the point it takes a southwardly turn (6).
• From the southwardly elbow turn, an extension canal may be excavated towards the desert…. just short of the international border with India.
• The canal may terminate in the old Rainee-Hakra-Ghaghar-Sarswati rivers bed and the water may be allowed to take its natural course southwards according to the south-west contours of the desert sand dunes parallel to the current Nara Canal on its east / the left side (7).
• With some training, the new canal / river can safely flow south, passing Hathungo and Chor on their east towards Mithi and South.
• On its way south, this Benazir canal / river would irrigate thousands of acres of virgin land, adding to the agricultural economy and turning the under ground and surface brackish water bodies into sweet water.
• Benazir canal may also serve as the first line of defense with the ever hostile India.
• Various branches of the existing Nara canal can be reinforced with additional supplies from the Benazir canal for the benefit of agriculture in Sanghar, Umerkot, Tharparkar and Badin districts.
• Depending upon the quantity of water and desert conditions, the canal / river is likely to have its delta / termination point some where in Tharparkar district in the desert or near the old abandoned port of Ali Bandar.

The proposal would hardly cost 25% of the otherwise expenditure, God forbids if anything happens to Sukkur Barrage in the event of larger summer flows in future.

With the proposed site for the spillway or a regulator at the abandoned old Nara canal site near Ali Wahan north of Rohri, hardly a few thousand people and acres of agricultural land are likely be affected.

Sukkur Barrage with the needed repairs and regulated flows is likely to get an additional life of at least fifty years.

Benazir canal would add new agricultural land, bring it under plow, desert would bloom, economy would improve and Sindh would Inshallah prosper – Aameen.

Kotri Barrage

• Increasing capacity of K.B.Feeder system for irrigation needs of Agriculture in Thatta district and raising of bunds and construction of reciprocating structures aiming at enhancing storage capacity of Keenjhar Lake.

The old abandoned river beds are at 8 and 9.

Please see more Maps in the next post...

No comments:

Post a Comment