Powered By Blogger

Wednesday, March 9, 2011

Pakistan:Is institutional silence the answer?

Not that more evidence was needed but the extent of intolerance that has come to haunt Pakistani society was again apparent in the National Assembly soon after the assassination of federal Minority Affairs Minister Shahbaz Bhatti on March 2. As the House rose to observe two minutes' silence for the Minister, who was gunned down near his residence in the federal capital earlier that day, three legislators kept sitting, refusing to show the most basic of courtesies extended to the dead.
As with Punjab Governor Salman Taseer, it was what ensued in the wake of Bhatti's assassination that denied the moderates of Pakistan the comfort of viewing religious fanaticism as something peripheral to their society.
Survival instincts made the political leadership — which anyway lives in perpetual wariness of its own shadow, courtesy various coups — run for cover. The always-ready-with-a-byte politicians were nowhere to be seen. Nor were their spokespersons bombarding reporters with condolence messages. To be fair, some of them, including Prime Minister Syed Yusuf Raza Gilani, attended the funeral service but …………….
By Anita Joshua
http://www.thehindu.com/opinion/lead/article1523576.ece?homepage=true

Sunday, March 6, 2011

Awan’s indictment in robbery!!!!

President Asif Ali Zardari has expressed ‘grave concern’ over the indictment of Federal Law Minister Babar Awan for robbery and attempted kidnapping. A Rawalpindi court on Saturday indicted Awan after the federal minister personally appeared before it and pleaded not guilty, rejecting charges against him as baseless and politically motivated.
Public reaction by the head of the state against a court decision comes as surprise, indicating the extent of conflict between the government and the judiciary. A statement issued by a presidential spokesperson, however, clarified that Zardari reacted to the indictment in his capacity as co-chairman of the ruling Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) and not as president. Farhatullah Babar said that the PPP co-chairman termed the pursuit of a case pursued over 12 years after the alleged incident occurred to be “an unfortunate and glaring abuse of judicial processes for settling scores with a political opponent even as lip service was paid to democratic values, pluralism and judicial independence.”
Experts, including Supreme Court Bar Association President Asma Jahangir, say the country’s ‘growingly independent’ judiciary was now overstepping its mandate at all levels, undermining the government and the parliament in some cases.
Babar Awan has served as defense attorney for Asif Ali Zardari when the president was responding to cases instituted against him.
The renewal of case against Awan by the Punjab prosecutor, a province where PPP’s opponent Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) is in power, comes amid heated politicking between the two groups in recent months.
The PML-N last month expelled from the provincial cabinet ministers belonging to the PPP in a move that put both the parties on a ‘path of confrontation’ with their eyes set on upcoming elections after three years of fragile alliance.
Awan has been one of the vocal PPP figures against the PML-N’s rule in Punjab.
“The PPP co-chairman also expresses the hope that civil society, the bar associations and enlightened public opinion will take serious notice of it and condemned the pursuit of 12 years old case for political ends through brazen abuse of the judicial processes,” said the spokesperson.
Zardari also said the PPP stood by all its workers who had rendered sacrifices for democracy and human rights. The party would protect its workers from political harassment and intimidation, the co-chairman said.

Saturday, March 5, 2011

A matter of deepest concern

President Supreme Court Bar Association Asma Jahangir says SC’s short order overruling the decision of a parliamentary committee not to grant extensions to six additional high court judges has undermined parliament and would “encourage unscrupulous individuals” to contrive their way up the bench.
Taking strong exception to the judgment, she reportedly said that the facts placed before the court raised more doubts about the selection process by the Judicial Commission rather than the parliamentary committee.
The record showed that the Judicial Commission disregarded the negative comments made by the chief justices of the high courts about the six additional judges, saying no reasons were given to explain why these remarks were not considered.
The 18th Amendment of the Constitution was amended by the 19th Amendment to accommodate the concerns of the Supreme Court, but parliament did not accept that their decision should ultimately be subject to judicial review, she said.
Relegating the parliamentary judicial commission to a rubber-stamp body defeated the spirit of the Constitution, she said. “The present short order has, in fact, amended constitutional provisions to take full control of appointment of judges by the Judicial Commission,” she said.
“It is a matter of deepest concern that the SC should collude with a petitioner who is promoting the interests of individuals who, by all accounts, were judged as very average but want to remain on the bench at all costs. Surely no grave injustice was done by dropping the substandard candidates. This cannot warrant a confrontation with parliament,” she said.